An audit report arrives with an accuracy score, several coding changes, and a recommendation for training. Before your organization acts, its managers need to understand how the reviewer reached those conclusions.

Which records were selected? What documentation was available? How were errors defined? Did the review team consider staff responses before finalizing findings?

These questions belong at the beginning of the selection process. Medical coding audit companies can differ in their reviewer experience, sampling methods, scoring, and approach to resolving disagreements. Those differences affect what your organization can conclude from the report.

A well-defined engagement gives coding managers and healthcare leaders findings they can examine, discuss, and use to guide corrective action.

Explore Cooper Thomas’s healthcare services when considering how an audit fits your organization’s coding and operational needs.

What Do Medical Coding Audit Companies Review?

Medical coding audit companies assess assigned diagnosis and procedure codes against clinical documentation and applicable coding requirements.

The engagement may examine inpatient facility records, outpatient encounters, professional services, or a particular specialty. Some reviews focus on one concern, such as modifier use or diagnosis sequencing. Others establish a broader baseline within a defined population.

Potential review areas include:

  • Diagnosis selection and sequencing.
  • Procedure code assignment.
  • Documentation supporting reported codes.
  • Evaluation and management coding.
  • Modifier use.
  • Inpatient diagnosis-related group assignment.
  • Consistency across coders or locations.
  • Recurring findings requiring education.

The scope should identify which elements are included and what the final report will address.

Start With the Decision the Audit Must Support

Define what your organization needs to learn before choosing a reviewer.

An audit investigating a recurring outpatient issue requires a different approach from a review intended to assess a newly assigned coding team.

Examples of audit objectives include:

Audit objectiveQuestion the review should address
Establish a baselineWhat findings appear within the selected records?
Investigate an error patternWhy does a defined issue keep recurring?
Assess a specialtyWhich coding concerns appear in this service line?
Evaluate trainingAre staff applying the guidance covered in education?
Review outsourced workDoes sampled work meet the agreed coding requirements?
Compare locationsAre coding practices consistent within comparable encounters?

Share the objective with prospective medical coding audit companies. Ask each to explain how its proposed method answers that question.

For an overview of audit types, read our guide to medical coding audit services.

Examine Reviewer Experience and Oversight

Ask who will perform the audit and who will review difficult or disputed cases.

Relevant experience should match the records involved. Inpatient facility review, outpatient procedures, and professional services each require attention to their own coding context.

AHIMA describes its Certified Coding Specialist credential as demonstrating coding proficiency and skills in data quality and accuracy. Credentials can inform your assessment alongside specialty experience and reviewer oversight. AHIMA Certified Coding Specialist. AHIMA

Request details about:

  • Experience with comparable encounter types.
  • Qualifications of assigned reviewers.
  • Secondary review procedures.
  • Methods for resolving complex questions.
  • Internal checks on reviewer consistency.
  • Use of subcontractors.

A company’s general experience should be supported by a staffing plan for your engagement.

Ask How Reviewer Independence Is Managed

Independence deserves a practical discussion.

If the audit provider also performs production coding, ask whether reviewers will assess their own work and how potential conflicts are managed. Identify who controls record selection and who approves final findings.

For an assessment of outsourced coding, establish whether your organization can select or approve the sample and examine the reviewer’s rationale.

Document the arrangement in the scope of work. The appropriate structure depends on the purpose of the review and your organization’s requirements.

Understand the Sampling Method

Sample selection determines what the audit examines and limits the conclusions that can follow.

A targeted sample may investigate a known concern. A random sample may support a different type of assessment. A sample divided by specialty or location may help compare defined groups.

Ask prospective medical coding audit companies to explain:

  1. The population eligible for review.
  2. How records will be selected.
  3. Why the proposed sample fits the objective.
  4. How exclusions will be handled.
  5. Which conclusions the design supports.
  6. Whether statistical inference is intended.

For example, a sample deliberately concentrated on previously flagged encounters may reveal the nature of a problem. Its findings should be interpreted in that context.

If you need estimates about a larger population, require the provider to explain the statistical design and assumptions before work begins.

Require Clear Scoring Definitions

An accuracy score can be calculated several ways.

Some audits measure the proportion of encounters without identified errors. Others measure correct codes or coding elements. Some assign different weights to different findings.

Request the formula and error definitions before reviewing quoted targets.

Scoring questionWhy to ask
What is the unit being scored?Establishes whether the measure concerns encounters, codes, or elements
How are errors classified?Explains what contributes to the result
Are findings weighted?Shows whether some errors affect the score more heavily
How are disputed findings handled?Clarifies when results become final
Are financial effects assessed?Defines any additional analysis and assumptions
Can results be broken down?Helps identify patterns within the sample

Ask for a worked example so your team can understand the calculation.

Verify the Standards Applied to Historical Records

Audits often include records from earlier reporting periods.

The reviewer needs the coding materials applicable to those records. CMS publishes ICD-10 code files, guidelines, and effective-date information that help identify the appropriate version. CMS ICD-10 resources. CMS

For applicable Medicare services, define how the review will consider National Correct Coding Initiative policies and edits. Medicare NCCI resources. CMS

When professional services include evaluation and management review, ask which guidance applies to the encounter category and reporting period. The American Medical Association maintains E/M coding resources. AMA evaluation and management resources. American Medical Association

The report should make its basis clear enough for your team to examine individual findings.

Request a Sample Report Before Selecting a Provider

A sample report helps your organization evaluate the deliverable.

Look for record-level findings that identify:

  • The original coding assignment.
  • The recommended correction.
  • Supporting documentation.
  • The reviewer’s reasoning.
  • Applicable references.
  • Unresolved questions or limitations.
  • The final disposition after discussion.

The summary should connect individual findings with patterns in the reviewed records.

Cooper Thomas’s medical coding and auditing services provide a starting point for discussing review requirements, reporting, and education.

Establish a Process for Discussing Findings

Preliminary findings may require clarification.

Your staff might identify documentation the reviewer did not see, raise an interpretation question, or provide relevant information about the encounter.

Agree on the response process before the audit begins. Set deadlines, define what supporting material can be submitted, and identify who performs secondary review.

Keep a record of:

  1. The preliminary finding.
  2. The organization’s response.
  3. Additional material considered.
  4. The reviewer’s final decision.
  5. Any remaining disagreement.

This creates a traceable path from initial observation to final report.

Prepare Documentation and System Access

Reviewers need the documentation relevant to the agreed scope.

Confirm how records, signed reports, amendments, and supporting materials will be available. Define how the reviewer requests missing information.

Workflow observations should be distinguished from confirmed coding findings so each can receive the appropriate response.

Cooper Thomas’s Health IT and EHR support addresses the technology and workflow context surrounding healthcare information.

HHS explains requirements for business associate agreements, including applicable arrangements involving subcontractors. Have your privacy team review the relationship before records are shared. HHS business associate guidance. HHS.gov

Connect the Report With Corrective Action

The final report should help your organization assign next steps.

A recurring issue might call for coder education, clarification of internal instructions, additional review, or investigation of documentation workflows.

For each action, identify the owner, expected completion date, and follow-up method.

Coordinate findings with your organization’s oversight process. The OIG’s General Compliance Program Guidance provides voluntary guidance on compliance infrastructure and related responsibilities. OIG General Compliance Program Guidance. oig.hhs.gov

Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Coding Audit Companies

How should we compare audit proposals?

Compare the review objective, encounter types, sampling, scoring, reviewer experience, reporting, discussion process, and follow-up scope.

Should an audit occur before or after billing?

Timing depends on the objective and workflow. Define whether the engagement is a pre-bill review, a retrospective assessment, or a combination.

Can an audit focus on one issue?

Yes. A targeted audit can address a defined coding concern. Its conclusions should reflect the population and records examined.

How many records should be reviewed?

The sample should fit the objective, population, and intended conclusions. Ask the provider to explain its rationale and any statistical assumptions.

Does audit pricing include education?

Confirm this in the proposal. Final reporting, training, corrections, and follow-up review may be separately scoped.

Discuss Your Coding Audit Objectives

Prepare a description of the records, reporting period, known concerns, and decisions the audit must support. Request a review method and deliverables that address those needs.

Learn more about Cooper Thomas’s healthcare focus and contact our team to discuss coding audit, review, and training requirements.