Two reviewers examine the same encounter and reach different conclusions. The coding team receives conflicting feedback, managers spend time reconciling the findings, and the original question remains unresolved.
This scenario highlights an important consideration when comparing medical coding auditing companies. The organization needs reviewers who can explain their decisions, apply a consistent method, and work through disagreements transparently.
The final report also needs to support action. Coding managers should be able to identify which findings require corrections, which call for education, and which need further investigation.
This guide explains how to evaluate reviewer consistency and turn an audit into a focused improvement process. Explore Cooper Thomas’s healthcare services when considering audit, coding, and operational support.
What Do Medical Coding Auditing Companies Provide?
Medical coding auditing companies review assigned codes against clinical documentation and applicable coding requirements.
An engagement may cover inpatient facility records, outpatient encounters, professional services, or selected specialties. The scope might focus on a particular issue or assess a defined sample more broadly.
Potential deliverables include:
- Record-level findings and explanations.
- Coding accuracy results.
- Summaries of recurring issues.
- Discussions of preliminary findings.
- Staff education.
- Corrective action recommendations.
- Follow-up reviews.
Specify each required deliverable in the agreement. Reporting, training, corrections, and follow-up may involve different responsibilities and pricing.
For an overview of audit types and planning considerations, read our guide to medical coding audit services.
Define What Staff Need to Learn From the Audit
An audit objective should connect to a decision your organization needs to make.
For example, a review may investigate recurring diagnosis sequencing findings, evaluate modifier use in a specialty, or assess whether staff are applying recent education.
Define the records, reporting period, and coding elements included.
| Audit purpose | Question to answer |
|---|---|
| Investigate repeated errors | Which issues recur, and what may be contributing? |
| Evaluate new staff | Which areas require additional support? |
| Review a specialty | What findings appear within comparable encounters? |
| Assess prior training | Are the targeted issues still present? |
| Examine external coding work | Does reviewed work meet the agreed requirements? |
| Compare teams | Are equivalent records reviewed consistently? |
Share these objectives with prospective providers and request a method that addresses them.
Evaluate the Reviewers Assigned to Your Records
Ask who will perform the review and who will handle complex cases.
The proposed team’s experience should match the encounter types and specialties within scope.
AHIMA describes its Certified Coding Specialist credential as demonstrating coding proficiency and skills in data quality and accuracy. Credentials can support an assessment alongside relevant experience and reviewer supervision. AHIMA Certified Coding Specialist. AHIMA
Request information about:
- Experience reviewing comparable records.
- Qualifications of assigned reviewers.
- Secondary review arrangements.
- How reviewer performance is checked.
- Preparation of replacement personnel.
- Participation of subcontractors.
Evaluate the staffing plan for your engagement alongside the company’s general capabilities.
Ask How Reviewers Establish Consistency
Before a large review begins, ask how the audit team confirms that reviewers interpret the scope, scoring, and reporting requirements consistently.
One approach is to have reviewers assess a small set of the same records, compare their reasoning, and resolve differences before continuing.
Ask prospective medical coding auditing companies how they manage this process and document decisions.
The discussion should address:
- Shared error definitions.
- Applicable coding references.
- Treatment of incomplete documentation.
- Scoring rules.
- Escalation of uncertain findings.
- Secondary review.
- Communication of resolved interpretations.
Documented decisions help reviewers apply the same approach throughout the assignment.
Confirm Which Guidance Applies to the Records
Audits may include encounters from earlier reporting periods.
CMS publishes ICD-10 code files, guidelines, and effective-date information. Reviewers should identify the materials applicable to the records being assessed. CMS ICD-10 resources. CMS
For applicable Medicare work, define how National Correct Coding Initiative policies and edits enter the review. Medicare NCCI resources. CMS
When professional services involve evaluation and management review, ask which guidance applies to the relevant encounter category and period. The American Medical Association maintains E/M coding resources. AMA evaluation and management resources. American Medical Association
The final report should make the basis of a finding traceable.
Require Findings That Staff Can Examine
A finding needs enough detail for your team to understand the reviewer’s reasoning.
Request a sample report before selecting a provider.
| Finding component | What it should explain |
|---|---|
| Record reference | Which reviewed encounter is involved |
| Original assignment | What was coded |
| Reviewer conclusion | What change is recommended |
| Documentation | Which record details support the conclusion |
| Rationale | How the reviewer applied relevant guidance |
| Staff response | What additional information was considered |
| Final disposition | Whether the finding was upheld, revised, or withdrawn |
A report should also identify unresolved questions and limitations.
Cooper Thomas’s medical coding and auditing services provide a starting point for discussing reporting, review, and education requirements together.
Establish a Fair Process for Discussing Disagreements
Disagreements deserve an organized review.
Your staff may identify documentation that was unavailable to the reviewer or raise a question about how guidance was applied.
Agree in advance on response deadlines, supporting materials, secondary review, and how final decisions will be recorded.
Track the preliminary finding and the reason for any change. If a disagreement remains, document it clearly rather than allowing it to disappear within the overall score.
Also explain how disputed findings affect accuracy calculations while the review is pending.
Separate Coding Errors From Workflow Observations
An audit may uncover issues involving record availability, document location, or communication.
These observations can require action, but they need to be evaluated according to their role in the reviewed work.
For example, a missing document may call for further investigation before the reviewer can finalize a coding conclusion. A recurring difficulty locating signed reports may warrant an EHR workflow review.
Cooper Thomas’s Health IT and EHR support addresses the technology and operational context surrounding healthcare information.
Define how reviewers request missing information and when a record is considered incomplete for the agreed audit.
Turn Recurring Findings Into Focused Education
Education should address the issues established during the review.
Group findings into meaningful topics and identify the intended audience. Coding staff, managers, and clinical teams may need different explanations and actions.
A focused education plan can include:
- The coding concept involved.
- An appropriately de-identified example.
- The documentation supporting the decision.
- The relevant reference.
- A practice exercise.
- A route for follow-up questions.
- A method for assessing later application.
Ask medical coding auditing companies whether education is included and how it relates to final findings.
Illustrative Example
Suppose several reviewed encounters show the same procedure coding issue.
Before scheduling training, confirm whether the findings reflect a knowledge gap, unclear internal instructions, or documentation that needs clarification.
If education is appropriate, build the session around the specific decision staff need to make. Then review comparable new records to assess whether the issue persists.
Plan Follow-Up Before the Initial Audit Ends
Agree on how corrective actions will be checked.
A follow-up review should identify the records, timing, method, and intended conclusions. Account for differences between the initial and subsequent samples when interpreting results.
Track responsibility for each action.
| Action | Evidence of completion |
|---|---|
| Staff education | Materials, participation, and addressed questions |
| Instruction update | Approved revision and communication |
| Record correction | Documented disposition under the organization’s process |
| Workflow adjustment | Tested handoff or system change |
| Follow-up review | Results and remaining issues |
Coordinate recurring findings with the appropriate internal oversight functions. The OIG’s General Compliance Program Guidance provides voluntary guidance on compliance infrastructure and related responsibilities. OIG General Compliance Program Guidance. oig.hhs.gov
Review Privacy Arrangements Before Sharing Records
External auditors may need access to protected health information.
HHS explains requirements for business associate agreements, including applicable arrangements involving subcontractors. Have your privacy team review the proposed relationship before records are shared. HHS business associate guidance. HHS.gov
Clarify approved access, work locations, information handling, incident reporting, and offboarding responsibilities.
Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Coding Auditing Companies
How can we assess reviewer consistency?
Ask how reviewers compare decisions, resolve differences, and apply documented interpretations throughout the engagement.
Should staff review preliminary findings?
Establish a response process that allows relevant documentation and reasoning to be considered before findings are finalized.
Does audit pricing include training?
Confirm the scope. Final reporting, education, corrections, and follow-up review may be priced separately.
Can follow-up results prove improvement across the whole organization?
The conclusion depends on the sample and method. Ask the provider to explain what the review supports and any limitations.
What should we request in a proposal?
Request reviewer qualifications, sampling and scoring methods, sample findings, the disagreement process, education deliverables, and follow-up options.
Discuss Your Audit and Education Requirements
Prepare a summary of the records, known concerns, prior findings, and questions your team needs answered. Identify how the results will inform education and operational decisions.
Learn more about Cooper Thomas’s healthcare focus and contact our team to discuss coding audit, review, and training requirements.